The short answer
When both numbers can't be played together, you still play as much as the rules allow. If only one number has a legal move, you play that one, even if it's the smaller die. If each number works on its own but not both, you must play the higher number. With doubles, you play as many of the four moves as you can.
So the higher die rule is real, but it's narrower than the popular shortcut of always reaching for the bigger number. It only applies when you have a choice between two numbers that each work alone. The four cases below each come with a board diagram; in every one you have the light checkers, move from your 24-point toward your 1-point, and are bringing your last stragglers home late in a game. Each position was checked with the Gamão.net rules engine.
Case 1: both numbers can be played — so both must be
If at least one sequence of moves plays both numbers, your move must play both. It doesn't matter that a one-die move looks safer or prettier; the rule is about what's legal, not what's good.
The trap is a move that is legal on its own but kills the other number. You can't make that move when a full play exists.
- Roll
- 6-4
- Correct play
- 16/12 9/3
- Not allowed
16/10
You rolled 6-4. Outside your home board you have one checker on the 16-point and one on the 9-point; three checkers are already off. Your opponent holds the 5, 6, 8, 14 and 21-points.
Correct play: 16/12 9/3. Move the 16-point checker four pips to the 12-point and the 9-point checker six pips to the 3-point. That's the only way to play both numbers.
Not allowed: 16/10. On its own, 16/10 is a legal 6 — but afterward no 4 can be played: 10/6 and 9/5 land on blocked points, and your home checkers can't bear off while a checker is outside. Since a play using both dice exists, 16/10 isn't allowed.
Position as text
Gamão game board from your side: you move from the 24-point toward the 1-point.
- You (light checkers): 1 on the 16-point, 1 on the 9-point, 1 on the 4-point, 3 on the 3-point, 3 on the 2-point, 3 on the 1-point; 3 already borne off.
- Opponent (green checkers): 3 on the 21-point, 3 on the 14-point, 3 on the 8-point, 3 on the 6-point, 3 on the 5-point.
Case 2: only one number can be played — play it, even if it's the lower die
Sometimes one number has nowhere to go no matter what you do first. Then you must play the other number, whichever die it is. Many players skip this case because they've memorized "play the higher die," but if the 6 is blocked everywhere and the 4 isn't, the 4 is mandatory.
- Roll
- 6-4
- Correct play
- 24/20
- Not allowed
24/18
You rolled 6-4. Your last checker outside is on the 24-point, four checkers are off, and your opponent holds the 14, 18, 21, 22 and 23-points.
Correct play: 24/20. The 4 is the only number with a legal move, so you must play it — even though it's the smaller die.
Not allowed: 24/18. Your 18-point is blocked, and after 24/20 the 6 is still stuck (20/14 lands on another blocked point). The 6 goes unplayed because it has no legal move, not because you chose to skip it.
Position as text
Gamão game board from your side: you move from the 24-point toward the 1-point.
- You (light checkers): 1 on the 24-point, 1 on the 4-point, 3 on the 3-point, 3 on the 2-point, 3 on the 1-point; 4 already borne off.
- Opponent (green checkers): 3 on the 23-point, 3 on the 22-point, 3 on the 21-point, 3 on the 18-point, 3 on the 14-point.
Case 3: either number, but not both — the higher die rule
This is the case the higher die rule was written for. Each number can be played by itself, but whichever you play first, the other one has no legal move left. You don't get to pick: the higher number must be played.
- Roll
- 6-5
- Correct play
- 24/18
- Not allowed
24/19
You rolled 6-5. Your back checker is on the 24-point; your opponent holds the 8, 13, 21, 22 and 23-points.
Correct play: 24/18. Both 24/18 and 24/19 are legal, but neither lets you play the other number: 18/13 and 19/13 both land on the blocked 13-point. When either die can be played but not both, the higher die is mandatory.
Not allowed: 24/19. 24/19 is legal by itself, but it plays the 5 when the 6 was also available.
Position as text
Gamão game board from your side: you move from the 24-point toward the 1-point.
- You (light checkers): 1 on the 24-point, 1 on the 4-point, 3 on the 3-point, 3 on the 2-point, 3 on the 1-point; 4 already borne off.
- Opponent (green checkers): 3 on the 23-point, 3 on the 22-point, 3 on the 21-point, 3 on the 13-point, 3 on the 8-point.
The order of the dice can decide everything
Before you conclude that a roll can't be played in full, try both orders. A blocked landing spot for one die may stop it from being played first, yet the same die may play perfectly well after the other one. If an order exists that uses the whole roll, you must find it and play it.
- Roll
- 6-4
- Correct play
- 24/20/14
- Not allowed
24/18
You rolled 6-4. Your checker is on the 24-point, your 18-point is blocked, and your 20- and 14-points are open.
Correct play: 24/20/14. Play the 4 first (24/20), then the 6 with the same checker (20/14). That uses the whole roll.
Not allowed: 24/18. Starting with the 6 is impossible because the 18-point is blocked. Playing just the 4 and stopping on the 20-point isn't allowed either — an order that uses both dice exists.
Position as text
Gamão game board from your side: you move from the 24-point toward the 1-point.
- You (light checkers): 1 on the 24-point, 1 on the 4-point, 3 on the 3-point, 3 on the 2-point, 3 on the 1-point; 4 already borne off.
- Opponent (green checkers): 3 on the 23-point, 3 on the 22-point, 3 on the 21-point, 3 on the 18-point, 3 on the 10-point.
Compare this diagram with case 2. Same roll, same checker, same blocked 18-point. The only difference is where three of your opponent's checkers sit — on your 10-point here instead of your 14-point — so 20/14 is open, and that turns "only the 4" into "both dice, in one order."
Doubles: as many of the four moves as possible
A double gives you four moves of the same number. Against a strong blockade, sometimes only one, two or three of them fit. Then you play every one you can; the rest are lost. Stopping after two moves when a third was legal is a common slip.
If no number can be played at all — for example, your checker is on the bar and both entry points are blocked — you lose your turn.
Myths that cost moves
Most rules disputes at a kitchen table come down to one of these:
- Myth: "I can skip a die if I don't like it." Reality: if the second number has a legal move, it gets played — even if it breaks your best point.
- Myth: "Higher die always wins." Reality: roll 5-2 with no legal 5 anywhere and a legal 2, and the 2 is the one you play.
- Myth: "If the 6 is blocked, it's dead." Reality: play the 4 first and the 6 may have somewhere to land.
- Myth: "A 6-4 is a 10." Reality: it is two hops, and the checker has to be able to stop after the first one.
- Myth: "With 3-3 I'll just play two." Reality: every one of the four 3s that can legally be played must be.
- Myth: "I'll move this one while the other waits on the bar." Reality: nothing else moves until the bar is empty.
Why the digital board won't let you make some moves
In a club game, an illegal play stands unless your opponent catches it. Online there is no one to argue with: before you can move your first checker, the Gamão.net engine works out every way your whole roll can legally be played, and only moves that start one of those plays are accepted.
So when a checker with an open path won't budge, the board isn't broken. That move would be fine on its own, but it would strand your other die when a full play existed — or spend the lower number when the higher one was required. Turn on "Highlight available moves" and the board lights up only the checkers and points that keep you legal.
A quick way to check if a move is legal
Over a physical board, run through these questions in order:
- Bar first: is any of my checkers on the bar? Enter it before anything else.
- Can I find any sequence that plays both numbers, in either order? If yes, my move must be one of those.
- If not: does only one of the numbers have a legal move? Then that number is mandatory, high or low.
- If each number works alone but they can't be combined, the higher number is mandatory.
- If neither number moves, the turn passes.
On doubles, ask a single question: how many of the four moves fit? Play exactly that many. For setup, hitting, bearing off and scoring, see the full backgammon rules.
Try it against the computer
Play a game without creating an account. The board only accepts legal moves, and with hints on it shows you where you can move.